Advertisement

Advertisement

The Gospel of Christmas Review: Great Songs, Thin Story

rainsmedia59Reviews19 hours ago23 Views

Filmnology Reviews Desk · 16 November 2026 · 5-minute read

Tyler Perry’s Netflix Christmas musical has the gospel royalty. Critics are split on almost everything else.

Tyler Perry’s The Gospel of Christmas is now streaming on Netflix, and it is not another Madea holiday outing. It is a faith-driven musical packed with gospel heavyweights, and the early reviews say it is far better at singing than storytelling.

Black Film Wire reports that the film has hit No. 1 on Netflix, so plenty of people are pressing play. Here is what it is about, what critics liked, and who should block out the evening.

What is The Gospel of Christmas about?

Perry wrote, directed and produced the film, which centres on Isaac, played by Durrell “Tank” Babs, a musician whose faith is wobbling. His wife Rebecca, played by Fantasia Barrino Taylor, leans on prayer to hold the family together. Ricco Ross plays Mr. Lived, a pawn-shop owner who stands in for temptation, and a chorus of angels supplies the lighter moments.

There is no Madea here, and very little of Perry’s usual soap-opera excess either. Instead, reviewers describe a straight drama of faith about losing it, testing it and getting it back. One critic called it a rushed mix of Miracle on 34th Street and The Preacher’s Wife.

The music is the main event

If critics agree on one thing, it is the soundtrack. Jeffrey Lyles lists Fred Hammond, CeCe Winans, Yolanda Adams, Smokie Norful, Ann Nesby and Shirley Caesar among the gospel names on show, with Kirk Franklin producing. Ready Steady Cut adds The Clark Sisters to that line-up and calls the soundtrack genuinely impressive, even though it disliked most of the rest.

Variety agrees that some songs are lovely and a couple are pop-gospel rousers, but says their mood clashes with the rest of the film. Lyles adds that the subplots feel like breaks between songs rather than stories in their own right. Put simply, the choir is the main course and the plot is the side dish nobody ordered.

Where critics say it falls short

The complaints are consistent. Variety calls the family story rickety and threadbare, like a sermon stretched to movie length, and says nothing in it is filled in convincingly. Ready Steady Cut is harsher, citing on-the-nose writing, amateur performances and moments that clash with the story.

Craft is another sore point. One review points to the opening scene, where Isaac smashes a bottle in frustration and the film never shows the key shots, as a sign of sloppy coverage. Lyles describes the film as underdeveloped and a step backwards for a director whose stage roots had been fading from his movies.

Perry has also been busy. Lyles counts this as the fourth film Perry has written, directed and produced in 2026, and Ready Steady Cut notes it lands barely a month after Doing Life. Some reviewers feel the pace shows.

Not everyone is gloomy. Variety singles out Ricco Ross as the one actor who gives his character more dimension than anyone else, and one critic says the film makes perfectly serviceable holiday viewing if you take it for what it is.

What the film has going for it

Having watched it, we think critics are underselling two things. The first is the casting. Fantasia Barrino Taylor and Durrell “Tank” Babs lead a line-up that also includes Ricco Ross and a roster of gospel stars, and the choices feel right throughout.

The second is the angels. The film places them in the raised section of the roof that sticks out above the house, and the image does a lot of work. It is a simple visual idea: angels live among people as spirits, waiting to act on prayer requests.

Spoiler warning: this paragraph describes the final scene. The devil’s messenger leaves the concert backstage and heads for the back exit, where archangels stand on either side to form an aisle. He walks through it in fear, and then a giant angel shining like gold appears in a flood of light, and the messenger trembles. It is the last moment of the film, and we think it is the most iconic one.

Who is it for?

Faith-focused outlets are much warmer. Black Film Wire calls it the most spiritually serious American Christmas film in years and recommends it for family viewing, while The Film Gordon praises its uplifting take on prayer, spiritual warfare and the Black church. The mainstream trade reviews lean the other way.

So the split looks like this. If you want a gospel concert with a Christmas bow on top, the reviews suggest you will be happy. If you want tight storytelling, you may want to manage your expectations.

The verdict

The consensus is easy to sum up: gospel royalty, great songs, thin story. Our view adds two more pluses: the casting and the angels, especially that final scene. Perry fans and faith audiences will likely find plenty to love, while viewers who want a polished drama may still find it frustrating.

The Gospel of Christmas FAQ

Where can I watch it? On Netflix.

Who directed it? Tyler Perry, who also wrote and produced it.

Is it a musical? Yes, with gospel performances throughout.

Is Madea in it? No, Madea does not appear in the film.

Sources: Variety, Jeffrey Lyles, Ready Steady Cut, AOL (syndicated review), Black Film Wire and The Film Gordon.

0 Votes: 0 Upvotes, 0 Downvotes (0 Points)

9.0 / 10Overall
Storyline 7.0
Cast 10.0
Cinematography 10.0
Soundtrack 9.0

The Summary

Tyler Perry wrote, directed and produced this Netflix faith-driven Christmas musical. It follows Isaac, a musician whose faith is wobbling, and his praying wife Rebecca (Fantasia Barrino Taylor), with a pawn-shop owner standing in for temptation. There’s no Madea in it.

Critics mostly praise the gospel-legend soundtrack but call the story thin and underdeveloped, with weak writing and craft. Faith-focused outlets are warmer. Our take adds that the casting and the angels are strong points, especially the spoiler-flagged final scene where the devil’s messenger walks past archangels and a giant gold angel appears.

Verdict: great songs, thin story. Perry fans and faith audiences will likely enjoy it, while viewers wanting a polished drama may be frustrated.

If you meant a summary of something else, such as the AMAA article, tell me and I’ll do that one.

Pros
  • Advantage Sample 1
Cons
  • Disadvantage Sample 1

Advertisement

Leave a reply

Advertisement

Advertisement

Join Us
  • Facebook38.5K
  • X Network32.1K
  • Behance56.2K
  • Instagram18.9K

Stay Informed With the Latest & Most Important News

Categories

Advertisement

Loading Next Post...
Follow
Search Trending
Popular Now
Loading

Signing-in 3 seconds...

Signing-up 3 seconds...

Cart
Cart updating

ShopYour cart is currently is empty. You could visit our shop and start shopping.